Skip to content
Dave
Join Dave

Premier League winners and losers: Jackson stops City as Bournemouth expose United and pressure grows on Sage

Nicolas Jackson gave Arsenal an opening, Bournemouth left Manchester United with questions that went well beyond their manager, and Crystal Palace failed another test under Pierre Sage.

By Verified HumanPublished
Add as preferred source
Nicolas Jackson scores for Aston Villa vs Man City

Nicolas Jackson gave Arsenal an opening, Bournemouth left Manchester United with questions that went well beyond their manager, and Crystal Palace failed another test under Pierre Sage.

Our Premier League winners and losers from matchweek eight look at whose weekend changed something, and whose problems became harder to ignore.

Opinion: Dave.Sport’s assessment of the weekend’s Premier League action.

Winners

Nicolas Jackson: the difference between pressure and points

Manchester City had opportunities at Villa Park. Aston Villa had Jackson.

His two goals secured a 2-1 victory, with the winner arriving just eight minutes after Erling Haaland had equalised. Rather than allowing City’s recovery to become the defining passage of the match, Jackson put Villa back in front.

Zion Suzuki deserves substantial credit too. City’s own report acknowledged the goalkeeper’s contribution as the visitors pressed.

This was not a match Villa controlled throughout. That makes the contributions at either end more significant: Jackson took the chances that mattered, and Suzuki helped ensure those goals were enough.

Bournemouth and James Hill: give the winners their due

There is a familiar danger whenever Manchester United lose: the opposition disappears from the discussion.

Bournemouth deserve better after winning 3-0 at Old Trafford. Rayan, Marcus Tavernier and Evanilson supplied the goals, but James Hill’s defensive contribution was another reason United could not find a route back.

Hill made 10 clearances, three blocks and a clearance off the line, according to Sofascore’s match analysis. The same provider recorded six big chances for Bournemouth and none for United.

Those figures support a more substantial verdict than simply calling the hosts poor. Bournemouth created the clearer openings and defended their own penalty area effectively.

Our Manchester United–Bournemouth report covers how they turned that advantage into three points.

Arsenal: an opportunity taken without Saka

There was nothing complicated about Arsenal’s assignment once City had lost: beat Everton and draw level on points.

They did it. Ezri Konsa and Gabriel scored in a 2-0 victory that took Arsenal to 21 points, alongside the leaders.

Winning without Bukayo Saka does not settle the question of how they would cope with a longer absence. One home match cannot do that. But it avoided allowing concern over Saka’s thigh injury to become an immediate setback in the title race.

On a weekend when a rival finally dropped points, Arsenal made sure the opportunity counted.

Andoni Iraola: Liverpool’s progress reaches Anfield

A first home league victory was overdue. Beating Brighton 2-0 gave Iraola that milestone and Liverpool a fourth successive win in all competitions.

The result also carried weight because of the opposition. Brighton arrived above Liverpool and remained only one point ahead after the match.

Alexander Isak’s goal, supplied by Bradley Barcola, offered another encouraging example of Liverpool’s attacking players combining. The next task is to sustain that improvement, with Florian Wirtz’s ankle problem an unwelcome complication.

A good run is taking shape. Liverpool now need it to survive the next difficult fixture.

Tottenham and Mathys Tel: something to build on

A 2-0 victory at Stamford Bridge is valuable enough on its own. Following the win over Coventry, it gives Tottenham consecutive league victories and a firmer basis for believing their form is improving.

Mike Penders’ own goal supplied the breakthrough, but Spurs were entitled to more than the suggestion they simply benefited from a mistake. Reuters recorded 70 per cent possession and 15 shots for the visitors.

Tel then finished the contest. His late goal ensured Chelsea’s error was followed by a decisive attacking contribution from Tottenham themselves.

Newcastle: a useful win before another examination

Newcastle’s 2-0 victory at Crystal Palace lifted them to seventh, with William Osula and Harvey Barnes scoring early in the second half.

Lukáš Horníček’s saves mattered too. Keeping Palace out while the match was level gave Newcastle the platform to make their stronger spell count.

Palace’s difficulties provide context, but they do not remove Newcastle’s achievement. This was an away win with a clean sheet, delivered through contributions at both ends.

James Trafford: saves that earned a point

Trafford’s four saves helped Leeds leave Sunderland with a 0-0 draw, including important first-half interventions against Brian Brobbey.

In a match short of convincing finishing, the goalkeeper made sure Sunderland could not turn their best openings into the winning goal.

He was a clear individual winner, even if neither team could be entirely satisfied with the result.

Losers

Michael Carrick: and the United team around him

Leaving Bruno Fernandes on the bench was Carrick’s decision. Losing 3-0 was a collective failure.

United’s winless run reached eight games in all competitions, and they finished the weekend 16th with seven points. Neither the selection debate nor speculation about the manager should obscure how little resistance they offered Bournemouth.

Carrick chose other substitutes while Fernandes remained unused. That decision inevitably attracts scrutiny when the team is chasing the game and still cannot recover.

But replacing the manager, if United choose to do so, would not itself explain how this group starts creating better chances and defending more reliably. Those problems belong to the club as well as the coach.

Pierre Sage: the response Palace needed did not arrive

The Newcastle game carried extra significance after Sky Sports reported that Palace wanted an improvement across the fixtures against Besiktas and Newcastle.

A draw in Istanbul was followed by a 2-0 home defeat. Palace have conceded 19 league goals in eight matches and seven without reply across their last two league games.

The damaging feature on Sunday was the speed with which a competitive match escaped them after half-time.

Our coverage of Sage’s position follows the reporting around his future. Whatever decision follows, Palace need to stop brief periods of poor defending deciding entire matches.

Chelsea: more than one goalkeeping error

Penders’ own goal will dominate the highlights. It should not carry the whole explanation.

Chelsea struggled to create enough, conceded the initiative to Tottenham and then lost Cole Palmer to a second yellow card. The dismissal made an already difficult recovery harder.

Goalkeeping mistakes happen. So do defeats in London derbies. The more concerning combination was a limited attacking performance followed by a loss of discipline.

Liverpool’s win then pushed Chelsea out of fourth place.

Manchester City: the margin for error shrinks

City belong here because they lost their perfect record and their points advantage over Arsenal.

They do not belong here as evidence of a crisis. Seven wins followed by a narrow away defeat remains a strong start, and the chances they created at Villa Park are relevant when judging the performance.

The consequence is nevertheless clear: Arsenal are level. City’s excellent opening has bought them a place at the top, not breathing room.

Hull: another lead without a win

Oli McBurnie’s first Premier League goal since April 2024 should have provided the basis for a more satisfying afternoon.

Instead, Dango Ouattara’s equaliser secured a 1-1 draw for Brentford and extended Hull’s winless league run to six games.

Brentford’s second-half changes helped alter the contest, as described in their official match report.

A point has value. But when victories have been scarce, failing to protect an advantage at home leaves a sharper sense of an opportunity missed.

Sunderland’s league position: still no escape

Sunderland stopped their run of defeats and kept a clean sheet against Leeds. Those are improvements, and the defensive work deserves recognition.

They still finished the weekend bottom.

Brobbey’s chances offered a route to something better, while the late danger from Sean Longstaff showed they could also have lost.

The draw was a step away from the performances that had brought successive defeats. It was not yet the result needed to move them off the foot of the table.

Next articleArsenal player ratings: Gyokeres shines as Raya helps secure Slavia Prague win
Add Dave as a preferred source on GoogleSee more of our stories in Top Stories