Man City beat Sunderland 5-3 to stay top with five straight wins

Standfirst

• Manchester City beat Sunderland 5-3 at the Etihad Stadium to make it five wins from five in the Premier League under Enzo Maresca.
• Antoine Semenyo scored twice either side of half-time, with Enzo Fernández, Rayan Cherki and Erling Haaland also finding the net for City.
• Brian Brobbey’s hat-trick, the first by a Sunderland player in the Premier League since Jermain Defoe in 2016, dragged the visitors to within a goal at 4-3.

Manchester City vs Sunderland: how it happened

Manchester City scored five to beat Sunderland 5-3 at the Etihad Stadium. They stay top of the Premier League. The defining moment came from Rúben Dias, who hooked a goal-bound effort off the line in the second half, protecting City’s lead at its most fragile point.

Semenyo put City ahead before the break. Brobbey levelled it at 1-1 with the first of his three goals. Semenyo struck again shortly after half-time to restore City’s advantage, before Brobbey found a second to make it 2-2 and set up a genuinely open finish.

Fernández and Cherki then took charge. The pair combined to push the score to 4-2. Brobbey completed his hat-trick to cut the deficit to 4-3, and it was in the minutes that followed that Dias made his intervention, clearing off the line as Sunderland pressed for a leveller.

Haaland settled it soon after. He converted his first ever goal against Sunderland to make the final score 5-3. Our full report on the 5-3 victory covers the goals in more detail, while the Guardian match coverage corroborates the scoreline and Brobbey’s record-breaking treble.

Five wins from five is City’s best start of the Maresca era so far. It keeps them clear at the top of the table heading into the next round of fixtures.

The expert angle: goalline heroics mask defensive fragility

Eight goals in one match tells its own story. City are scoring for fun under Maresca. Four different players got on the scoresheet against Sunderland, but three of the goals they conceded came from one striker exploiting the same soft spots repeatedly.

Brobbey’s hat-trick was no fluke. It came from City allowing Sunderland back into the game three separate times: first to 1-1, then to 2-2, and finally to 4-3. A team conceding at that rate against a promoted side will find fewer margins for error against the division’s better attacks.

That is what makes Dias’s clearance the game’s real turning point, not a footnote. Sunderland were pushing hard at 4-3. City’s back line looked stretched. One missed intervention would have levelled the match for a third time and changed the entire complexion of the result.

Maresca will be delighted with five wins from five. He will be less delighted that his side needed an acrobatic block on the line, rather than a settled defensive shape, to see the game out. Haaland’s late goal was the difference between a comfortable finish and a nervy one. The underlying pattern of games slipping away defensively is the one worth watching.

City remain top and unbeaten. The attacking numbers are extraordinary this early in the season. But a back line that has now shipped three goals to a newly promoted club’s forward line is a fair question for the manager, even in victory.

What happens next for Maresca’s side

The immediate priority for Maresca is shoring up a defence that has looked porous even while the team wins games. Five from five is a record worth protecting. Doing so will mean tightening up against sides who will fancy their chances of repeating Brobbey’s afternoon.

There is plenty happening away from the first team too. City’s academy has enjoyed its own bright start, with our report on how five wins launch new Manchester City U18 era showing the pipeline is producing results at every level of the club.

Off the pitch, supporters heading to the Etihad will notice changes at the turnstiles too, after news that an expanded SeatGeek deal keeps ticket system intact for the rest of the campaign.

For now, City sit top of the Premier League with a perfect record. Whether that record survives contact with sterner opposition will depend on Maresca finding defensive solutions as convincing as his side’s finishing.

Follow all the latest: Football live: Premier League 2026/27 news, transfers and updates.