Newcastle v Arsenal player ratings: Madueke earns an 8 as Miley tests both keepers
Our marks for every starter and substitute in Newcastle’s 2-2 draw with Arsenal, as Noni Madueke rescued a point and Lewis Miley tested both goalkeepers.
Back to Match Centre
Newcastle v Arsenal![]()
Noni Madueke hit the post, was denied by both goalkeeper and defender, then rescued Arsenal with a 78th-minute equaliser. At the other end, Lewis Miley tested both Arsenal keepers as Newcastle turned a 1-0 half-time deficit into a 2-2 draw. Our marks are out of ten.
Premier League PredictorPredict this matchweek’s scores. Free to play.Play nowNewcastle United player ratings
Lukáš Horníček — 8 Blocked Madueke at close range and kept out Eze’s free-kick before the break. Will feel he could have done better with Madueke’s equaliser, even with the deflection.
Amar Dedić — 5 Booked in the first half and replaced at the interval as Newcastle changed the right side.
Malick Thiaw — 8 Quickest to the rebound when Raya denied Willock. His first goal of the season briefly put Newcastle ahead.
Dan Burn — 7 On his 200th Newcastle appearance, lost his marker at a corner and headed the ball back into danger for Thiaw’s goal.
Lewis Hall — 6 Havertz took the ball off him for the opener. Recovered to deny Madueke from six yards and caused problems with his corners.
Sean Steur — 5 Could do little to slow Arsenal through midfield before the break. Ramsey replaced him at half-time.
Lewis Miley — 8 Made Raya deal with one fierce effort and forced Kepa into another save at 2-1. Continued to offer a goal threat from midfield.
Jacob Murphy — 6 An ambitious early shot drifted wide. His next effort clipped Barnes and went much closer before he gave way to Elanga.
Joe Willock — 7 His effort after Burn’s header forced the parry that Thiaw converted. A telling contribution against his former side.
Harvey Barnes — 8 Timed his run to meet Osula’s pass and finished for his 100th career goal. Combined with the striker again to create a chance for Miley.
William Osula — 8 Won the ball high up the pitch and waited until Barnes was clear to release him. The clearest example of what changed after half-time.
Substitutes: Tino Livramento 7, Anthony Elanga 7, Jacob Ramsey 7, Yoane Wissa 6, Sven Botman unrated. The three half-time changes let Newcastle press further up the pitch. Botman came on in added time.
Arsenal player ratings
David Raya — 6 Stopped Willock in the scramble for Newcastle’s second and dealt with Miley from distance. Went off injured with Arsenal 2-1 down.
Jurriën Timber — 6 Had a quieter first half before Barnes and Osula found a route behind Arsenal on his side.
Ezri Konsa — 6 Helped keep Newcastle at arm’s length before the break. The home forwards gave him much less time once the press stepped up.
Gabriel — 6 A comfortable opening half gave way to a much tougher contest in his own six-yard box. Arsenal never dealt with the corner for 2-1.
Riccardo Calafiori — 6 Got far enough forward to drag a shot wide during Arsenal’s best spell. Had Elanga to contend with after the break.
Bruno Guimarães — 6 Nearly scored against his old club when he met Rice’s cross. His influence faded as Newcastle won more second balls.
Declan Rice — 7 Created that opening for Guimarães and helped Arsenal control midfield before half-time. Booked as Newcastle gained the upper hand.
Noni Madueke — 8 Our player of the match. Kept finding space on the right after three first-half chances went begging. At 2-1 down he took Ødegaard’s pass, cut inside and beat Horníček with a deflected left-foot shot.
Martin Ødegaard — 6 Lost possession to Osula in the move for Barnes’s equaliser. Made amends on the counter, picking out Madueke on the right for 2-2.
Eberechi Eze — 8 Set himself and beat Horníček for the opener. Almost added a second with a free-kick just before half-time.
Kai Havertz — 7 Robbed Hall and found Eze for 1-0. Nearly undid that work when he headed a Newcastle corner onto the top of his own bar.
Substitutes: Kepa Arrizabalaga 7, Christos Tzolis 6, Myles Lewis-Skelly 6. Kepa’s stop from Miley kept Arsenal one goal behind. Viktor Gyökeres and Mikel Merino came on in added time and are unrated.
Read our Newcastle 2-2 Arsenal match report or revisit the key moments at St James’ Park.



