Newcastle vs Arsenal prediction: Alan Shearer, Jamie Carragher and Chris Sutton all back the Gunners
Alan Shearer, Jamie Carragher and Chris Sutton all predict an Arsenal win at Newcastle. Jack Shaw on what the pundits said before the 5.30pm kick-off.
Back to Match Centre
Newcastle v Arsenal![]()
Alan Shearer wants Newcastle to win. He just cannot bring himself to predict it. The club’s record goalscorer has backed Arsenal to win at St James’ Park on Saturday evening, and Jamie Carragher and Chris Sutton agree with him.
Premier League PredictorPredict this matchweek’s scores. Free to play.Play nowKick-off is 5.30pm GMT on Saturday 21 November. Follow the line-ups, score and stats on our Newcastle vs Arsenal match centre.
Shearer’s Newcastle vs Arsenal prediction: heart against head
Shearer was honest in his Betfair predictions, published by Metro. “This is a tough one to predict,” he said. “I’d love to see Newcastle win, but that would be my heart ruling my head.”
“I think it’s a tough game because of the way Arsenal are playing at this moment in time, and the way Newcastle are. I have to say an away win.”
For Shearer, it all comes down to Arsenal’s back line. “The problem is Arsenal are so brilliant defensively,” he said. “Over the last few years, Arsenal have known that coming to St James’ Park because of the atmosphere is a tough game, and I’m expecting the same, but I just think that Arsenal might nick it by an odd goal.”
That will sting on Tyneside. When a Newcastle legend picks the away team, it says a lot about where both clubs are right now.
Carragher goes for 3-1, Sutton for 2-0
Carragher is even more confident. In his Sky Bet Super 6 prediction, reported by football.london, he backed the champions to win 3-1. “After Arsenal stretched their lead at the top to five points, I’m confident they’ll leave Newcastle with a win!” he said.
Sutton went for 2-0 in his BBC column, and his words were the sharpest of the three. “I think it is a huge one for Newcastle boss Matthias Jaissle,” he said. “The Magpies have picked up as many points, 12, in their first 10 games under Jaissle as they did when Eddie Howe was in charge last season, but I still don’t think their fans are overly convinced by him.”
“Some of their unease is because Newcastle don’t seem to have a defined style of play, and can be a bit kamikaze going forward. Because of that, I just think Arsenal will pick them off, and win comfortably.”
He also had a warning for the rest of the league. “The worry for their rivals is that it feels to me Mikel Arteta’s side have not even got going yet, but I still don’t see anyone being close to them.”
Why the pundits all lean the same way
The numbers explain it. Arsenal top the table with 27 points from ten games. They have won nine, lost one and conceded only five league goals. Brighton are second, five points back.
Newcastle sit 12th on 12 points with a goal difference of minus three, and that is why Sutton’s word “kamikaze” will hurt.
There is also a big personal story. Bruno Guimaraes returns to St James’ Park for the first time since his move to Arsenal, as we covered in our Newcastle vs Arsenal preview. Arsenal have William Saliba back but are without Bukayo Saka and Martin Zubimendi.
Shearer is right about one thing above all: St James’ Park can change a game. Three pundits have picked Arsenal. Newcastle have the chance to prove all three wrong, and to give Jaissle the big win his doubters want to see. For more from the top flight, visit our Premier League hub.



