Skip to content
Dave
Join Dave

Alan Shearer questions Leeds penalty for Morgan Rogers handball as Keith Hackett backs referee

Alan Shearer felt Leeds should not have had a penalty at Chelsea. Joe Hart questioned the call, while Keith Hackett said Morgan Rogers deliberately used his arm.

Add as preferred source
Morgan Rogers handball: Morgan Rogers celebrating for Chelsea
dave.sport library

Alan Shearer said Leeds United should not have had a penalty for Morgan Rogers’ handball in their 4-1 win at Chelsea. Former Premier League referee Keith Hackett backed Michael Oliver’s decision, saying Rogers deliberately used his arm to steer Jayden Bogle’s shot away.

The sides were level at 1-1 early in the second half at Stamford Bridge when Bogle struck the ball from the edge of the area. Oliver pointed straight to the spot. His decision stood after a VAR check and Dominic Calvert-Lewin put Leeds ahead in the 53rd minute.

Premier League PredictorPredict this matchweek’s scores. Free to play.Play now

What Hart saw in the replay

“Not a penalty for me,” was Shearer’s verdict on Match of the Day. Joe Hart was less certain. The former England goalkeeper questioned whether Rogers had made himself bigger, but also disputed the Chelsea player’s gesture towards his face. Hart said the shot had not struck him in the mouth.

Hart wanted Oliver to see the incident again at the pitchside monitor. He also acknowledged that once Oliver had given the penalty, the video assistant needed clear evidence to recommend a review.

Why Hackett backed Oliver

For Hackett, the key was how Rogers moved as the shot came towards him. “Rogers uses his arm and moves his body to steer the ball away,” the former refereeing chief told MOT Leeds News.

Chelsea’s match report described the contact as high on the arm. Under IFAB’s handball law, the arm starts level with the bottom of the armpit. For a defender, contact below that line is an offence if it is deliberate or if the arm makes the body unnaturally bigger for the movement the player is making.

That leaves two questions about the replay. Was Rogers’ arm in a natural position as he turned? And did he move it towards the shot? Hart saw little evidence that Rogers had made himself bigger, while Hackett judged the movement deliberate. Under the Premier League’s VAR guidance, the on-field call stands unless the footage shows a clear and obvious error.

Leeds scored twice more through Noah Okafor and Brenden Aaronson to claim their first league win at Stamford Bridge since 1999. Our Chelsea 1-4 Leeds match report has the goals and our Premier League hub has the updated table.

Next articleJason Cundy warns Xabi Alonso could lose Chelsea job after 4-1 Leeds defeat
Add Dave as a preferred source on GoogleSee more of our stories in Top Stories