Danny Murphy questions Alex Scott’s fit at Liverpool and urges Iraola to look again at Gravenberch
Danny Murphy does not see Alex Scott as a defensive midfielder and says Liverpool's real problem is tactics, urging Iraola to bring back Gravenberch at the base.
Danny Murphy doubts Alex Scott could protect Liverpool’s defence when both full-backs push forward and wants Andoni Iraola to give Ryan Gravenberch another chance in the role he played under Arne Slot.
Scott, who played under Iraola at Bournemouth, has been linked with Liverpool and Chelsea in a deal that PariuriX says could cost more than £100m. “I don’t see Alex Scott as a defensive midfielder,” Murphy told the Romanian outlet, in comments also reported by the Liverpool Echo.
Premier League PredictorPredict this matchweek’s scores. Free to play.Play nowWhy Danny Murphy doubts Alex Scott can play holding midfield
Murphy said Scott is a player he admires, but questioned whether he has the athleticism of top holding midfielders such as Moisés Caicedo and Declan Rice. In a side that wants to push forward and attack, he said, the deepest midfielder has to cover a huge area of the pitch.
He also said Adam Wharton, whom he described as more of a classic defensive midfielder, is not playing particularly well at the moment.
‘Tactics are the biggest problem’
Murphy believes Iraola’s midfield problems are tactical rather than about the players. He said Liverpool need one of their midfielders, whether Trey Nyoni, Alexis Mac Allister or Gravenberch, to be more disciplined, and that tactics are the biggest problem in the middle of the pitch.
He has criticised the squad before. Last week he said Milos Kerkez lacks composure and quality.
Murphy wants Gravenberch back at the base
Murphy pointed to Gravenberch, who played as the deepest midfielder when Liverpool won the Premier League under Slot in 2024-25. He said that season showed Liverpool’s midfielders could be more solid and compact, and that Gravenberch proved he could do the job with a bit more discipline. He wants Iraola to try him there again.
Iraola’s options have been limited by Gravenberch’s fitness. The Dutchman missed the trips to Fenerbahçe and Crystal Palace with a fractured heel, and Iraola said before the Palace game that his availability depended on the pain. The latest is in our Liverpool injury news.
Liverpool vs Man Utd next
Whether Gravenberch is fit to return will be one of Iraola’s main selection decisions when Liverpool host Manchester United at 4.30pm on Sunday 22 November, in Mauricio Pochettino’s first game in charge. All the details are on our Liverpool vs Man Utd match page.
For all the latest, follow our Liverpool hub and the Premier League hub.



