Kilmarnock vs Aberdeen player ratings – Nisbet leads the way
Kevin Nisbet leads the ratings after scoring twice in the opening 12 minutes of Aberdeen’s 4-2 win. Both benches influenced the result, with Tyreece John-Jules dragging Killie back…
Back to Match Centre
Kilmarnock v Aberdeen![]()
Kevin Nisbet leads the ratings after scoring twice in the opening 12 minutes of Aberdeen’s 4-2 win. Both benches influenced the result, with Tyreece John-Jules dragging Killie back into it and Findlay Marshall eventually taking it beyond them.
Premier League PredictorPredict this matchweek’s scores. Free to play.Play nowKilmarnock player ratings
Nico Mantl – 6/10. Conceded four but still made five saves. Nisbet alone put four attempts on target.
George Stanger – 5/10. Got upfield for two efforts, but the Dons were through twice before Killie had really settled.
MJ Kamara – 4/10. A difficult afternoon centrally against Nisbet, whose second goal left the hosts chasing from the 12th minute.
Michael Schjonning-Larsen – 7/10. A genuine attacking outlet, putting two of three efforts on target even as Killie struggled defensively.
Cathal McCarthy – 5/10. Offered a shot of his own but the visitors were much more efficient when they reached his end.
Tom Lowery – 5/10. Four attempts, none on target. Getting into good positions was only half the job with Killie behind.
Aaron Tshibola – 5/10. Could not keep the Dons midfield away from the danger area. Lyons had the third before half-time.
Ieuan Owen – 7/10. Supplied Kiltie’s goal and tested Müller himself. His delivery helped bring a lopsided start back to life.
Erik Ring – 5/10. Little direct threat in a match where his team-mates managed 21 attempts between them.
Joe Hugill – 6/10. Tested Müller once but picked up a yellow as the search for an equaliser continued.
Greg Kiltie – 8/10. All three shots on target. His goal gave Rugby Park hope just seven minutes after Nisbet’s double.
Kilmarnock substitutes
Mark O’Hara – 6/10. Introduced at the break as the home side set about repairing a two-goal deficit.
Tyreece John-Jules – 8/10. Needed just three minutes and one shot to score after Müller’s mistake. Changed the feel of the contest.
Rory McKenzie – unrated. Came on in the 85th minute just before Aberdeen restored their two-goal lead.
Nicky Clescenco – unrated. Too little time to make a fair assessment after his late introduction.
Jamie Brandon – 6/10. Got an effort away after coming on at the interval and helped sustain the second-half pressure.
Aberdeen player ratings
Marius Müller – 6/10. Six saves were important but the error that let John-Jules score left the result in doubt for half an hour.
Gavin Molloy – 7/10. Needed to deal with a remarkable 14 corners. The visitors eventually saw off that sustained aerial pressure.
Jack Milne – 7/10. Got an attempt away and helped keep the visitors ahead during the long spell at 3-2.
Ante Palaversa – 6/10. Part of a back line that gave up plenty of shooting opportunities but held out when Killie threatened an equaliser.
Nesta Guinness-Walker – 8/10. Supplied Lyons for the third, restoring the cushion after Kiltie had given the home crowd a lift.
Nicky Devlin – 7/10. Got forward for an effort and had plenty to do against a side constantly attacking his penalty area.
Stuart Armstrong – 8/10. Picked out Nisbet for the opening goal and tested Mantl with his own attempt.
Alexander Briedl – 6/10. Had to do more defending than attacking as the visitors won with under half the possession.
Brad Lyons – 8/10. One attempt, one goal. The former Killie captain’s contribution before half-time proved especially valuable after the restart.
Hicham Mahou – 6/10. Got one effort away but the decisive work in front of goal came from his strike partner.
Kevin Nisbet – 9/10. Two goals in four minutes left the home defence scrambling. Kept Mantl occupied beyond that opening burst too.
Aberdeen substitutes
Lewis Smith – 6/10. Introduced with the game still at 3-2 and saw it out after Marshall struck.
Findlay Marshall – 8/10. Took his one shooting chance in the 86th minute to finally settle a game Killie kept threatening to rescue.
Ayoub Mouloua – 8/10. Two attempts on target and the assist for Marshall. A substantial contribution from the bench.
Afeez Aremu – 6/10. Came on alongside Mouloua shortly after the second Killie goal and helped protect a narrow lead.
See the Kilmarnock vs Aberdeen match centre and full match statistics.
Archive photograph of Stuart Armstrong at Old Trafford in 2022 by Ardfern, CC BY-SA 4.0.



