Ashley Young explains why he backs Jordan Pickford over James Trafford for England
Ashley Young says Jordan Pickford has earned his England place and is better on the ball for Tuchel, even after James Trafford's late saves against Spain.
Ashley Young says Jordan Pickford should keep his England place because he trusts the Everton goalkeeper more with the ball at his feet. James Trafford’s stoppage-time double save secured Sunday’s 3-2 win over Spain, but Young believes Pickford gives Thomas Tuchel the better option when England play out from the back.
The former England winger, who played alongside Pickford for England and Everton, made the case on The Overlap Daily, as reported by Yahoo Sports.
Premier League PredictorPredict this matchweek’s scores. Free to play.Play nowTuchel: ‘There’s no No 1’
Tuchel has refused to name a first-choice goalkeeper. “There’s no No 1,” he said after the win in Madrid, as reported by Sky Sports. He also praised Trafford’s composure when Spain pressed him.
Pickford, 32, has not started four of England’s last seven competitive games, having missed only two of the previous 41. He has been England’s first choice since 2017, and only Peter Shilton, with 125 caps, has made more appearances among England goalkeepers.
Ashley Young on Jordan Pickford
“I’m more confident in Pickford than Trafford with his feet,” Young said.
He said England play out from the back far more than Everton do, and that Pickford shows his quality on the ball more for his country because Tuchel wants that style. He also praised Trafford for the saves he made late in the Spain game.
Young pointed to Pickford’s record as well. The Everton goalkeeper has 94 caps, has played at three World Cups and two European Championships, and has kept 49 clean sheets.
Trafford leads Pickford on Premier League shot-stopping
Trafford, 24, has the best save ratio in the Premier League at 82.2%, and has prevented 4.4 goals, according to Goal. Pickford’s figures are 73.7% and 1.1.
Trafford has made mistakes, including an error that Evanilson punished in Leeds’ recent defeat by Bournemouth. Without Pickford across their last nine competitive games, England kept two clean sheets and conceded 18 goals.
You can read how Tuchel’s three changes delivered against Spain.
What happens next
England will learn their Nations League quarter-final opponents at 11am GMT on Friday 20 November. Our England Nations League draw piece covers their possible opponents.
For more, see our England news and Everton news pages.



