Skip to content
Dave
Join Dave

Why Arsenal should have had a penalty against Hull with Kai Havertz in an offside position

The Premier League's Key Match Incidents panel says Arsenal should have had a penalty against Hull, Coventry were wronged at Everton and Man Utd's equaliser against Villa was correct. James Chettle explains the round 10 verdicts.

Add as preferred source
Kai Havertz playing for Arsenal against Hull at the Emirates

Arsenal should have been awarded a penalty against Hull even though Kai Havertz was in an offside position, the Premier League’s Key Match Incidents (KMI) panel has ruled.

The five-person panel reviewed two penalty appeals involving Havertz and Hull’s Nobel Mendy in Arsenal’s 1-0 win at the Emirates on 7 November. It backed the referee on the first and unanimously disagreed with the outcome on the second, according to its round 10 decisions.

Premier League PredictorPredict this matchweek’s scores. Free to play.Play now

The panel also found that Coventry were wrongly denied a penalty at Everton, backed Manchester United’s late equaliser against Aston Villa, and split over a tackle in Leeds’ game with Tottenham.

Why Mendy’s foul on Havertz took precedence

All five panellists backed referee Farai Hallam’s decision to wave play on after Mendy’s 12th-minute challenge on Havertz. They reached the opposite verdict for the 42nd minute.

Havertz was already in an offside position, but Mendy held him before he became involved in play. Under Law 11, a player in an offside position is only penalised on becoming involved in active play, so the foul came first. VAR Michael Oliver was right to recommend a review, and Arsenal should have had a penalty, the Premier League said.

Martin Odegaard’s 72nd-minute goal meant the decision did not cost Arsenal.

It was the second successive round in which the panel found Mendy had escaped conceding a penalty for holding. Four of its five members said Ipswich should have had one when he held Dara O’Shea in the 18th minute of their 2-2 draw at Hull. The panel unanimously backed the no-penalty decision on a separate appeal involving the same two players three minutes later.

Tarkowski hair pull should have been a penalty

The second unanimous error came in Everton’s 3-1 win over Coventry on 6 November. James Tarkowski held Caleb Yirenkyi’s hair as the Coventry player challenged for the ball in the 38th minute. Nothing was given on the pitch and VAR did not intervene.

The panel said a penalty and a yellow card should have followed and that VAR should have stepped in. Three players were sent off for hair pulling in the Premier League last season, when it was treated as violent conduct. This season, the guidance is a red card for a clear, deliberate pull with excessive force or brutality, and a yellow card otherwise.

Dorgu equaliser stands, Bogle splits the panel

Patrick Dorgu’s header in the sixth minute of stoppage time, which earned United a 4-4 draw with Aston Villa at Old Trafford, was correctly allowed, the panel ruled 5-0. United goalkeeper Senne Lammens, who had gone up for the corner, turned away from the ball and made contact with Villa keeper Zion Suzuki, but the contact was not impactful enough to be a foul.

The panel voted 5-0 to uphold the decision to disallow Dan Burn’s 33rd-minute header for Newcastle at Fulham. Newcastle team-mate Yoane Wissa held Timothy Castagne, preventing the Fulham defender from challenging Burn.

The panel split 3-2 twice on Jayden Bogle’s challenge on Mathys Tel in Leeds’ game with Tottenham on 7 November: once on referee John Brooks’ decision and once on VAR Tony Harrington’s decision to let it stand. In both votes, three members felt the challenge was reckless but below the red-card threshold, while two felt Bogle should have been sent off.

What the numbers say

Of 27 key incidents in round 10, the panel judged 78 per cent of on-field decisions to be correct, below the season average. Across all 223 incidents so far this season, 85 per cent of on-field decisions have been correct, rising to 97 per cent after VAR.

Earlier this month, the panel ruled that Liverpool should have had an Isak penalty against Arsenal, so Arsenal have been on both sides of its verdicts in a fortnight.

For all the latest, visit our Premier League hub.

Next articleAshley Young tells Man Utd to sign Morgan Gibbs-White and build around him as Bruno Fernandes weighs his future
Add Dave as a preferred source on GoogleSee more of our stories in Top Stories