Skip to content
Dave
Join Dave

Dietmar Hamann says Man City should lose points and pay compensation if appeal fails

Dietmar Hamann says Manchester City should lose points and compensate rival clubs if their appeal fails. He also questioned how relegation would affect the Championship promotion race.

Add as preferred source
Dietmar Hamann doing punditry work

Dietmar Hamann says Manchester City should lose points and pay compensation to rival clubs if they lose their appeal against the Premier League’s financial rule findings. The former City midfielder also questioned what relegating his old club would mean for Championship teams chasing promotion.

City maintain their innocence and lodged their appeal on 1 October. The independent commission has yet to decide a sanction. Hamann’s call for a “hefty points deduction” came in an interview with GOAL published on 18 November.

Premier League PredictorPredict this matchweek’s scores. Free to play.Play now

Why Dietmar Hamann raised the Championship promotion race

Asked whether he could see City playing in the second tier next season, Hamann described the conflicting predictions he had heard. One person had suggested a 70-point deduction. Hamann himself gave no figure.

“But anything other than financial compensation and a hefty points deduction, I’d be surprised,” he said.

His concern about relegation centred on the three places available in the Premier League each season. Two Championship clubs go up automatically and a third through the play-offs. Hamann argued that clubs already competing for those places would see City as another obstacle to promotion. He did not name a club or suggest that the EFL had taken a formal position.

What the commission found against Manchester City

The decision published by the Premier League on 29 September covered nine seasons, from 2009-10 to 2017-18. The commission upheld all the charges relating to serious breaches of the league’s financial rules and three of four charges concerning co-operation with the investigation.

The commission found that some sponsors paid only part of their agreed fees and that City’s then owner, Abu Dhabi United Group, funded the balance. It found that the arrangements, alongside the way costs were recorded, overstated the club’s financial position by more than £900m. City disputed the findings when they appealed and said their evidence supported their position.

Why Danny Mills cited Everton and Nottingham Forest

Former City defender Danny Mills made a separate argument in an October interview with GOAL. He said a token punishment would be “an absolute farce”, pointing to the points Everton and Nottingham Forest lost for breaching the league’s spending rules.

Everton lost eight points across two cases in 2023-24: six for the first breach after an appeal and two for the second. Forest lost four points. Neither case decided how the commission should deal with the separate findings against City.

When is Manchester City’s appeal likely to be heard?

The Financial Times reported on 13 November that the appeal was expected to be heard in mid-December and could last several days. Its sources expected a ruling in the new year. If the findings are upheld, the commission would then consider the penalty.

Our Manchester City appeal report has more on the expected timetable.

Next articleCoventry vs Crystal Palace preview: Thomas Frank’s first test in relegation clash
Add Dave as a preferred source on GoogleSee more of our stories in Top Stories