Skip to content
Dave
Join Dave

Paul Ince urges Man Utd to sign Ollie Watkins or Ivan Toney instead of Victor Osimhen

Paul Ince says Man Utd still need a 25-goal striker, doubts Benjamin Sesko as a starter and would choose Ollie Watkins or Ivan Toney over Victor Osimhen.

Add as preferred source
Ollie Watkins celebrates scoring for England

Paul Ince says Manchester United still need a “25-goal man” and should target Ollie Watkins or Ivan Toney rather than Victor Osimhen.

The former United midfielder was speaking in an interview with GOAL. United are 18th in the Premier League after dropping into the relegation zone before Michael Carrick was sacked, and Mauricio Pochettino takes charge for the first time at Anfield on Sunday.

Premier League PredictorPredict this matchweek’s scores. Free to play.Play now

Watkins or Toney over Osimhen

Osimhen, now at Galatasaray, has been linked with a Premier League move for years. Ince would instead go for two strikers now in Saudi Arabia: Watkins, who joined Al-Hilal from Aston Villa in the summer, and Toney, who plays for Al-Ahli.

Watkins scored 27 goals in all competitions for Villa in 2023-24, including 19 in the Premier League. Toney scored 20 in 33 league appearances for Brentford the previous season.

“I like Osimhen, I’ve watched him play a lot in Turkey this year,” Ince said. “But for me, you’ve got two players you can go and get. Go and get Ivan Toney or go and get Ollie Watkins. Both proven Premier League players.

“I know they’re playing in Saudi for a sack full of money, but if you’re looking for out-and-out strikers who are proven in the Premier League, go and get Ollie Watkins or Ivan Toney, someone like that, because they do create chances.

“Manchester United have created so many chances this season. They just can’t find the back of the net. Whether that can happen in January, I don’t know.”

United lost 3-0 at home to Bournemouth on 25 October and drew 4-4 with Aston Villa at Old Trafford on 8 November.

Why Paul Ince questions Šeško’s starting role

Benjamin Šeško joined from RB Leipzig in August 2025 in a deal worth up to £73.7m. He scored 12 goals in all competitions in his first season, many of them as a substitute.

“When you look at Šeško, you think of last year, the amount of times he came off the bench and scored vital goals,” Ince said. “But that was coming off the bench. Every time he started, he never really seemed to do it. Maybe he looked at himself as more of a super sub than actually starting the game.”

Ince also questioned how United have used their other forwards. He pointed out that Matheus Cunha played on the left at Wolves and Bryan Mbeumo on the right at Brentford, yet both have been used up front.

“They’ve never really gone and said, ‘we need to find that 20, 25-goal man who’s going to score those goals’,” he said.

What it means for Pochettino

Fabrizio Romano reported this week that United want a centre-back and a striker in January, partly because of Šeško’s fitness problems, as covered in our Man Utd transfer news round-up. Šeško is also expected to miss the trip to Liverpool with a shin injury, according to our Man Utd injury news.

Follow the fallout across the league on our Premier League hub.

Next articleConor Bradley and Giovanni Leoni back in Liverpool training as Szoboszlai plays 90 minutes before Man Utd visit
Add Dave as a preferred source on GoogleSee more of our stories in Top Stories